Most degenerative meniscus tears, meaning those that come without a specific injury have the capacity to actually heal themselves! When looking at how to heal a torn meniscus naturally, there are a few things that will make you successful. Non-operative management is possible, with the right movement program, inflammation control, and regaining your confidence. Surgery is considered in some circumstances and I’ll discuss how you know if your torn meniscus requires surgery below.
Meet one of my clients who reached out to me with this story:
Her knee did not feel stable and she was having pain that kept increasing. She began avoiding activity because she was scared she was making things worse.
She saw her primary care doctor who then referred her to an orthopedic surgeon. The surgeon wanted to go ahead with surgery but she got a different opinion which advised against surgery.
She had luck with PT but was looking to return back to her normal activities.
We started working together, talking through the fact that some pain and discomfort is okay. That she wasn’t causing more damage with every twinge of pain she felt.
She started becoming less fearful of movement. She started getting stronger.
She was even able to start running again, which was huge! She is back to playing tennis and mountain biking with her e-bike.
For her, she wasn’t sure if surgery was for her but did seek out further assistance to make her decision. Now she is thriving because she learned how to treat her torn meniscus naturally!
If you have a degenerative meniscus tear, you usually have a few options when it comes to treatment. These include:
- Physical therapy or medical exercise
- Meniscus repair (usually arthroscopic): cleaning of meniscus
- Meniscectomy (partial or full, arthroscopic or open): removal of meniscus, partial and arthroscopically is the most common procedure
Researchers have been comparing these three things for many years to decide which is the best. When looking at how to heal a torn meniscus naturally, one of the best bets is on physical therapy and exercise.
But how effective is it really? Let’s take a look.
Is exercise effective for a torn meniscus?
I took a deep dive into the research to find out the true possibilities of healing a torn meniscus naturally. Here’s what was found.
- In a study of 102 people with knee pain and a degenerative horizontal tear of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus- average age 53.8 years old- half got meniscectomy surgery and half got physical therapy/strengthening exercises. BOTH groups had similar pain reduction, improvements in function, and satisfaction after a two year follow up.
- Another study looked at those receiving physical therapy after partial meniscectomy and supervised exercise alone, without surgery. Interestingly, those that received surgery first did not have any better results than those that just did exercise. Both groups had “decreased knee pain, improved knee function and a high satisfaction”
- A systematic review analyzed 6 different studies around operative versus non-operative meniscus treatment and found: “The results of this systematic review strongly suggest that there is currently no compelling evidence to support arthroscopic partial meniscectomy versus physical therapy.”
Are you starting to see a pattern here?
In most circumstances, the Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy is no better than traditional exercise alone when it comes to looking at pain and function.
So resources on how to heal a torn meniscus naturally are critical to your success as surgery may not be the most efficacious option anyways.
The key here is knowing which exercises are not going to flare up your pain and will actually bring you the same benefits as found above.
Before I dive into how to heal a torn meniscus naturally, I do want you to know there are certain circumstances where surgery is recommended and these criteria below can help you decide.
Should you get meniscus surgery?
A very interesting study laid out the parameters when it comes to deciding on surgery, particularly the APM or Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy procedure.
“According to the current algorithm of the 2016 ESSKA Meniscus Consensus Project, the messages regarding APM were as follows:
APM should not be considered as the first-line treatment choice;
APM should only be proposed after a proper standardized imaging protocol;
APM can be proposed after three months of persistent pain/mechanical symptoms or earlier in cases with considerable mechanical symptoms;
No APM should be proposed with advanced osteoarthritis on Schuss view.”
This means that you should try other options before jumping the gun to surgery. This is why learning how to heal a torn meniscus naturally is very important.
The new approach to modern surgery is no longer “if it’s torn, take it out” but instead replaced with “Save the meniscus!” which is why you see many surgeons advising conservative treatment first.
It is important to note that conservative management will not work perfectly for everyone and some will have to go and have surgery. I do know many that have found relief following the surgery but also some that have “never been the same”.
Watch this video below to help you with this decision if you are feeling stuck:
How to heal a torn meniscus naturally
Step 1: Finding the RIGHT movement
This is hands down one of the most important steps when it comes to your meniscus healing. Movement can be extremely powerful in this situation but you have to make sure you are doing the right things.
Many people try exercise but end up causing more pain or further injury because they aren’t doing the right things.
Muscle strengthening is one of the best ways to improve pain and instability related to an injured meniscus. Strengthening the muscles in your leg truly help to provide support to your knee joint.
Why is muscle support necessary? A meniscus helps to absorb the stress from daily movement to protect your knee. When the meniscus is torn, it doesn’t work as well and more stress goes to the knee. If you have appropriate muscle strength, your muscles can now compensate for some of the lost meniscus function.
So where should you begin? Here is a video example of the 6 best exercises you can try if you have a torn meniscus.
Please be advised, all of these exercises may not feel great to you and that’s okay! It is important to choose 2 or 3 to incorporate into your daily routine.
Step 2: Stay Active
Contrary to popular belief, rest may not. bethe most important thing in your healing journey. Too often we rest, thinking we are doing our joints. a favor but in reality this can lead to more joint stiffness and pain.
Minimize the time you are stationary to <2 hours at a time. You will see a dramatic increase in your mobility if you increase the amount of time you are moving throughout the day.
Even simply completing movements when you are sitting can help to reduce joint stiffness and thus decrease pain.
Inactivity can actually lead to muscle weakness, increased irritation, and increased inflammation which leads to difficulty moving around.
Step 3: Use a Knee Sleeve
Knee sleeves can help significantly with improving stability and decreasing pain. they can also help to control knee swelling if it is problematic for you.
I love these because they don’t impede your range of motion and are relatively inexpensive. Here is my top 11 list of the best knee sleeves.
These can be very helpful in getting you through more exercise. andmore activity without flaring up your pain.
Step 4: Control Inflammation
This can be done in a variety of ways including food, stress management, avoiding overactivity, and getting proper sleep. If you have high levels of inflammation in your body, it can negatively impact healing ability of your meniscus.
Here is a list of the best anti-inflammatory foods to help you get started on your journey.
A good rule of thumb is to get at least 7-8 hours of sleep. If you have a hard time sleeping due to pain, you can try heat or ice before you go to bed (make sure you don’t sleep with it though), light movement/stretching, and gentle massage to help with pain flares.
Overactivity can lead to further inflammation so it is important to listen to your body and watch how much activity your joint can handle. If you walk 30 minutes one day and ontice pain afterwards, try 20 minutes the following day to see if you experience less pain. Continue to modify as needed. Here is a video to help.
Making the right decision for your meniscus
Whether you decide to go the natural, conservative route or the surgical route, I want you to feel confident in this decision.
You can make the best of both situations and you have to choose what is best for you. Weigh all of your options.
It is possible to learn how to heal a torn meniscus naturally and actually be successful with it. With dedication and consistency you will be able to thrive even with. a meniscus tear.
Meniscus tears are very common and there are options for treatment. You don’t have to give up everything you love because of a meniscus tear. Hang in there!
The Arthritis Adventure Blueprint
Dr. Alyssa Kuhn’s signature program to help you go from hopeless to hopeful with osteoarthritis. You will learn the secrets to arthritis pain relief that actually work- including exercise, diet, and other ways to control inflammation! Say goodbye to short term pain relief, it’s time to make it last.